Doj to give oversight panel more fast and furious documents attorney general jeff sessions announced wednesday that the department of justice doj will provide documents to congress on the obamaera program dubbed fast and furious that allowed criminals to purchase guns in phoenixbased gun shops in order to track them into mexico. The contempt citation disregards the fact that for more than a year, the committee has been holding the attorney general to an impossible standard by demanding documents that the department is prohibited by law from producing, including records covered. Its up to congress to enforce it and they have proven to be spineless chickenshits more afraid of losing their seat than doing what is right. District judge amy jackson berman rejected the executive privilege claims of the obama administration in withholding documents from a house committee looking into the fast and furious gunwalking scandal. Congress does not arrest and detain people for ignoring its subpoenas anymore, but it still has significant power to. Court orders doj to provide some fast and furious documents. The following pages in the reissued report contain material, highlighted in yellow, that was previously redacted. Obama invoked executive privilege to help eric holder conceal fast and furious documents from congressional investigators and the american public. The vote follows a roughly 16month investigation by the chambers house oversight and government reform committee into the failed gunrunning sting known as fast and furious run by the bureau of alcohol, tobacco, firearms and explosives, a division of the justice department led by holder. Chairman of the house oversight committee darrell issa is back on the fast and furious trail and announced the issuance of a. The justice department said friday that it had given to congress additional documents related to the botched gunsmuggling operation known as fast and furious. The battle over the mueller report and other records created a reason for the house to seek to settle the fast and furious case. Judge rules doj must share documents from fast and furious.
Continued 11102014 this is part two of a twopart series discussing efforts in federal court to force the department of justice to disclose documents relating to operation fast and furious that are subject to both a congressional subpoena and an assertion of executive privilege by the president. Not so fast and furious settlement in congressional. Assertion of executive privilege over documents generated in. Those responsible for allowing fast and furious to proceed and those who. House panel recommends holder be cited for contempt updated at 4. Operation fast and furious louis fisher the constitution project in his.
In 2014, under a court order, the justice department produced nearly 65,000 pages of documents related to operation fast and furious that had been sought by the oversight committee. The justice department, however, continues to withhold documents critical to understanding decision making and responsibility in operation fast and furious. During operation fast and furious, the largest gunwalking probe, the atf. New oversight chairman jason chaffetz subpoenas holder. Subpoena fight over operation fast and furious documents finally. Holder admits lies in fast and furious, refuses to resign. Fox news is reporting that president obama has granted an 11thhour request by attorney general eric holder to exert executive privilege over fast and furious documents, a lastminute maneuver that appears unlikely to head off a contempt vote against holder by republicans in the house. This suit also resulted in a ruling in favor of the houses ability to bring suit to enforce its subpoenas in a decision by a judge appointed by president obama.
However, both congress and the executive branch lost on longheldand cherishedlegal arguments they had deployed in the tussle over information access. In an acute sense, that is true judge jackson ordered the justice department to produce sensitive. Department of agriculture and the office of management and budget for documents. Were fighting all the subpoenas, trump told reporters at the white house on wednesday. Obama asserts executive privilege on fast and furious. In 2012, there was another subpoena lawsuit brought by house republicans related to the botched guntrafficking case known as operation fast and furious.
The house of representatives voted to hold attorney general eric holder in contempt of congress thursday for failing to provide documents relating to the fast and furious gunwalking program. Lynch, the subpoena enforcement litigation related to the house oversight and government reform committees investigation into operation fast and furious. Resolved, that the speaker of the house shall otherwise take all appropriate action to. The justice department on friday night provided congress with a new batch of operation fast and furious documents from early 2011. The department of justice has turned over nearly 65,000 pages of documents on the fast and furious gunrunning scandal to the house committee on oversight and government reform, the panel. House panel sues holder over fast and furious docs politico. The background, causes and effects of the miers and fast and furious investigations and litigations are detailed in morton rosenberg, when congress comes calling.
Obama relents on fast and furious documents cbs news. Attorney general eric holder faced scrutiny from the republicandominated house judiciary committee on thursday regarding the fast and furious initiative. Obama administration fails to comply with subpoenas for. It is clear that congress does have several important legislative purposes for its investigation, and the particular facts of the operation fast and furious scandal both in. The fight over the subpoena for fast and furious documents wasnt settled till 2019. Nearly four years after the house found thenattorney general eric holder in contempt for failing to turn over fast and furious documents, the white house has backed off its claim of. A study on the principles, practices, and pragmatics of legislative inquiry, the constitution project, pp. Congress does not arrest and detain people for ignoring its subpoenas anymore, but it still has significant power to demand witnesses and documents, and republican president donald trump is putting that power to the test. This post has been updated with the pdf file of the complaint.
Whether president barack obamas assertion of executive privilege over some of these documents is proper remains to be seen, but the american people and the victims families deserve some answers. Lynch is a subpoena enforcement case that rests on whether the president can assert dpp to withhold records reflecting, not the development of policy, but the development of responses to congress and the media. Holder has been subpoenaed over fast and furious before and in june 2012 became the first sitting attorney general in history to be held in criminal and civil contempt of congress for failing to. Despite congressional subpoenas, obamas attorney general eric holder has refused to turn over more than 90 percent of the vital documents that pertain to this scandal. Past attorney general went unpunished for contempt. Justice sends more fast and furious documents to congress. Overall, throughout the litigation, congress has prevailed in its efforts to obtain rulings designed to pry more records from the department related to operation fast and furious. This memo explains key events and facts in operation fast and furious that have been.
Et voting on strictly partisan lines, a house committee recommended 2317 wednesday that attorney general eric holder be cited for contempt of congress for failing to turn over documents relating to the botched fast and furious weapons sting operation. Posted on april 15, 2016 by paul mirengoff in fast and furious, holder justice department, house of representatives documents confirm eric holders role in fast and furious coverup fast and. Generally speaking, the documents at issue are about how and if the obama administration misled congress about the fast and furious matter. On september 4, 20 chairman hastings issued subpoenas to the u.
President obama asserted executive privilege on documents dated after february 4, 2011. Gunwalking, or letting guns walk, was a tactic used by the arizona u. Congress of internal executive branch documents generated in the course of the deliberative. When the congress subpoenaed fast and furious documents. Inspector general is investigating the conduct of fast and furious. I do think every president has probably done something impeachment worthy. Protecting the houses institutional prerogative to. General eric holder for additional documents related to fast and furious. Attorney general eric holder in contempt of congress over. This order forces the obama doj, for the first time and by october 1, 2014, to provide a detailed index of all documents that it has withheld from congress and the american people for years about the deadly. Washington president barack obama has asserted executive privilege over documents sought by a house committee investigating the. Enforcing executive branch compliance congressional research service 2 obligation to comply with a duly issued and valid congressional subpoena, unless a valid and overriding privilege or other legal justification permits noncompliance. Obama amnesty contempt for law atf supervisors of botched gun sting get promoted.
The obama administration had for the last four years refused to provide the records to house republicans, invoking a claim of executive privilege. More evidence holder lied to congress in another document dump late last friday evening, the obama department of justice doj released 500 pages of records, including internal email correspondence, regarding the exploding scandal known as fast and furious, where the bureau of alcohol, tobacco and. Congressional investigators issued a subpoena wednesday for communications relating to operation fast and furious. The oversight committee is demanding previously undisclosed documents about the dojs response to fast and furious, a gunrunning operation in which u. The move follows a june vote holding him in contempt of congress. Holder be proceeded against in the manner and form provided by law.
When congress subpoenas executive branch officials with questions of privilege, the two sides either reach an ac. Subpoena fight over operation fast and furious documents. Doj to give oversight panel more fast and furious documents. Subpoena fight over operation fast and furious documents finally settled. The same day, at a full committee markup, chairman hastings stated his plans to issue subpoenas if the administration failed to respond in a timely manner. Documents confirm eric holders role in fast and furious. Mexico comes demanding documents of fast and furious, now.
Dissenting atf agents came forward to congress in response. House panel sues holder over fast and furious docs. Holder defied a congressional subpoena to furnish documents about operation fast and furious, a program to attempt to trace gun trafficking along the southwest border that went awry. Congresss contempt power and the enforcement of congressional subpoenas congressional research service 1 introduction congresss contempt power is the means by which congress responds to certain acts that in its view obstruct the legislative process. Both congress and a district court judge has demanded that the administration release all relevant fast and furious documents and every day that passes is another reminder that despotism has infected the executive branch once again, the constitution provides a means for removing despotic and tyrannical members of the executive branch. House panel recommends holder be cited for contempt this. Pdf pdf provides a complete and accurate display of this text. This points out the often protracted legal fights subpoenas go through, probably why speaker ryan did not allow further subpoenas to proceed. Court rules congress cannot sue to force executive branch. Congress is trying to get documents that were created after feb. Media outlets generally reported it as a win for congress and loss for the executive. The measure now goes to the full house for consideration, expected next week, of what would be an. I have long maintained that the refusal of the administration to turn over material to this and other committees is denial of. Read cnns fast facts about operation fast and furious, the atf phoenix field divisions allowance of illegal gun sales to track sellers and.
1290 1437 1225 1166 1376 1080 109 395 368 579 275 486 1075 1420 266 151 1064 640 626 1489 141 44 418 1275 1120 130 1133 492 1240 176 998 892 1000 432 430 1315